Supreme Court: Schools Cannot Override Parents’ First Amendment Rights
Published on scotusblog.com
In a decisive 6–3 ruling, the Supreme Court affirmed that public schools may not override parents’ constitutional right to direct the religious upbringing of their children.
In Mahmoud v. Taylor, the Court held that Montgomery County Public Schools violated the First Amendment when it refused to notify parents or allow opt-outs for elementary instruction involving LGBTQ+ themed storybooks. The majority made clear this was not about “micromanaging curriculum,” but about preventing the state from compelling young children to participate in instruction that directly conflicts with their families’ religious beliefs.
Importantly, the Court found that the district’s policy did more than expose students to ideas — it substantially interfered with religious development, a burden that triggers the highest level of constitutional scrutiny. The justices rejected the district’s claim that opt-outs were unworkable, noting that schools already allow them in other sensitive areas such as sex education.
This ruling has national implications. While the case arose in Maryland, the constitutional principles apply to every public school district in the country. Parents now have clear legal footing to request notice and opt-outs when instructional content crosses into matters of faith, gender, or sexuality.
Parents’ Rights in Education urges families to understand this decision, engage proactively with their schools, and exercise these rights before policies are quietly shaped without parental input.
Content credit to scotusblog.com